lying in ponds
The absurdity of partisanship
Home | About | Philosophy | Methods | Contact | FAQ | 2002 | 2003

Pundit Boxscore for Thursday 9 September 2004

DOWD REPEATS EXTRA-CHROMOSOME COMMENT: Robert Cox at The National Debate criticized Maureen Dowd last month for using the term "extra-chromosome conservatives" in a TV appearance, attributing it to the late Lee Atwater. Ms. Dowd repeated the comment in her Sunday column.

I'm confused -- why would Maureen Dowd revive the appalling practice of using extra-chromosome as a political attack? Ms. Dowd seems to be citing Mr. Atwater's use of the term approvingly, despite the fact that two different vice presidents (George H.W. Bush and Al Gore) have apologized to the Down Syndrome community for using it, as documented by Bob Somerby at The Daily Howler. Strangely, the reason for Mr. Somerby's research in 2001 was yet another Maureen Dowd reference to the same thing in a column back then. So why is Ms. Dowd so enamored of the term; is she unaware of the Bush and Gore incidents in 1987 and 1994? Mr. Somerby says that George Bush's gaffe was not widely reported, but even I remember Al Gore's apology in 1994.

UPDATE: Robert Cox says he will pursue the issue with The New York Times and the National Down Syndrome Society.



Lines in yellow indicate a substantive crossover column, meaning that the column is of opposite sign to the pundit's Normalized Total PI for the season, and contains at least five non-neutral partisan references.
Lines in gray indicate that the pundit has been classified as inactive, meaning that their columns are not currently being evaluated for partisanship.
Democratic references in blue, Republican in red, positive references in bold, negative in italics.
Author/
Affiliation
Title/
Date
words PI Partisan References
Bill O'Reilly
BillOReilly.com
Say It Ain't So, Ted Turner
9 September 2004
755 100 8D-,7R+
So now: James Carville, Paul Begala, Kerry
In the: GOP, John Kerry
A central: Republicans
But when: Kerry, Bush, Mary Matalin
The CNN: President Bush
The fact: Bush, Cheney
Personally, I: Carville, Begala, Kerry
Richard Cohen
Washington Post
Red Scare, Updated
9 September 2004
961 89 5D+,1D=,1R+,28R-,1R=
Let's play: Cheney, Dick Cheney, John Kerry, Joseph McCarthy, Cheney
Cheney made: Cheney, Cheney, Joe McCarthy
Cheney, of: Cheney, George Bush, Clinton administration, Sandy Berger, administration
In a: Cheney, vice president, Bush administration, Bush
It was: Cheney, Cheney, Cheney, Cheney, Cheney
The problem: Cheney, John Kerry, George Bush, President Bush
The other: Madeleine Albright, Henry Kissinger, Kerry, Bush, Cheney
Sorry, Henry,: Henry, Cheney, Bush, McCarthy, Cheney
Ann Coulter
Universal Press Syndicate
The more John Kerry changes, the more he stays the same
9 September 2004
942 88 19D-,3D=,3R+
The more: John Kerry
There's been: Democrats, Vice President Cheney, Democrats
I believe: Democrats
Of course,: John Kerry
The only: Kerry
Republicans have: Republicans, Kerry
While waiting: Kerry, Kerry
During the: Democratic, Kerry
But a: Kerry, Kerry
As I: Kerry, Kerry
The "family": Kerry
Speaking to: Kerry
But a: Kerry, Kerry, John Kerry
So the: Kerry
While Kerry: Kerry, Bush
Maureen Dowd
New York Times
Cheney Spits Toads
9 September 2004
996 78 9D+,3D-,1R+,26R-,1R=
Cheney Spits: Cheney
WASHINGTON —: George W. Bush, Dick Cheney, the president's father, Bush, Cheney
The terrible: vice president
Without Zell: Zell Miller, Cheney
He finally: Bush, John Kerry
"Because if: Cheney
These guys: John Kerry, Democrats, Kerry, Bush administration, Kerry, White House
It's like: Cheney
The vice: vice president, president, Kerry
Mr. Cheney: Cheney, John Kerry, President Bush, Republicans, Democratic president
Mr. Cheney: Cheney, Bush, Bush, Bill Clinton, Sandy Berger, Bushies, Clinton, The president
After the: Bush administration, White House
For a: Bushies, Bush
As the: White House
Molly Ivins
Creators Syndicate
Forget Bush
9 September 2004
938 77 2D+,2D=,8R-,1R=
Forget Bush: Bush
09.09.04 -: FDR
There are: White House, White House
If the: president
When the: White House, Condoleezza Rice, the president
When a: administration
Forget Bush: Bush, John Kerry, Clinton, Clinton
George F. Will
Washington Post
Bad News for Kerry
9 September 2004
926 75 7D-,3D=,8R+,2R=
Bad News: Kerry
After two: John Kerry, George W. Bush
The atrocity: Pat Moynihan
The Bush: Bush administration
James W.: Bush, Bush, Republicans
Kerry is: Kerry, Bush, Kerry, Bush
Hence he: Bush, Kerry
In his: Kerry
But when: Democratic, Kerry
Almost any: Bush, Kerry, Bush
OJ On the Editorial Page
WSJ OpinionJournal
Conned in Caracas
9 September 2004
688 57 10D-,2D=,2R-
New evidence: Jimmy Carter
Both the: Bush Administration, former President Jimmy Carter
This is: Carter, Carter
The new: Carter, Carter
"This result: Carter, Carter
None of: Carter, Carter
Yes, it: Colin Powell, Carter, Carter
WP Lead Editorial
Washington Post
Mr. Powell and Darfur
9 September 2004
544 40 2R-,3R=
Mr. Powell: Powell
SECRETARY OF: Colin L. Powell
Earlier in: Powell
Now U.S.: Powell
The United: Powell
NYT Lead Editorial
New York Times
Unraveling Kerry's Iraq Plan
9 September 2004
1234 12 7D-,14D=,3R+,6R-,4R=
Unraveling Kerry's: Kerry
Nobody gets: John Kerry, Democratic, President Bush, Bush, Kerry, Kerry, the president, Democrats
Despite our: Kerry, Kerry, Bush
Still, voters: Kerry, Democrats, Kerry, Bush
None of: Kerry
Many of: Kerry, administration, Bush administration
But Mr.: Kerry
That is: President George Bush
Mr. Kerry's: Kerry, Bush, Democrats, Bush administration
One thing: Kerry, Bush, Cheney, Kerry, Bush administration
Although Mr.: Kerry
Given the: Kerry, Kerry
David S. Broder
Washington Post
The Price Of Labor's Decline
9 September 2004
896 7 1D-,6D=,7R=
Because the: Republicans
True, President: President Bush, John Kerry, Bush, Kerry
Today, the: Democratic, Republicans, Richard Nixon, Jerry Ford, GOP
Politicians took: Democratic, Kerry, Dick Gephardt, Howard Dean
Thomas Sowell
Creators Syndicate
Jobs and snow jobs
9 September 2004
762 0 1D-,1R-
 Senator John: John Kerry
 President Bush's: President Bush
Jeff Jacoby
Boston Globe
Where is the Muslim outrage?
9 September 2004
776 0