lying in ponds
The absurdity of partisanship
Home | About | Philosophy | Methods | Contact | FAQ | 2002 | 2003

Pundit Boxscore for Wednesday 28 April 2004

O'REILLY NOT A FACTOR: When readers voted for Bill O'Reilly to be added to the Lying in Ponds roster for this year, they may have expected him to contend for the partisanship title with heavyweights like Ann Coulter and Paul Krugman. So far though, the O'Reilly factor has been non-existent -- he's currently ranked 29th out of 33 in the rankings, right next to the unquestionably non-partisan David Broder.

Mr. O'Reilly certainly leans Republican, but he has displayed two traits that the more partisan pundits rarely show -- he's written several mostly non-political columns on cultural topics, and he's dished out some substantive criticism of his own party. With the remainder of 2004 likely to be dominated by the presidential election, there are ample opportunities for Bill O'Reilly or other pundits to ramp up the partisanship, but I suspect that Mr. O'Reilly has an independent streak which will continue to keep him out of the Lying in Ponds Top Ten.



Lines in yellow indicate a substantive crossover column, meaning that the column is of opposite sign to the pundit's Normalized Total PI for the season, and contains at least five non-neutral partisan references.
Lines in gray indicate that the pundit has been classified as inactive, meaning that their columns are not currently being evaluated for partisanship.
Democratic references in blue, Republican in red, positive references in bold, negative in italics.
Author/
Affiliation
Title/
Date
words PI Partisan References
Harold Meyerson
Washington Post
Prince Hal vs. King Henry
28 April 2004
994 88 17D+,1D-,1D=,20R-,2R=
In the: John Kerry
The sentences: George W. Bush, Bush
The Republicans: Republicans, Kerry
We could,: Bush, Republican, Bush
Kerry's leadership: Kerry, Republican, Kerry, Sam Johnson, Kerry
What Kerry: Kerry, Kerry, Nixon administration
The war: Nixon, Kerry, administration
It was: Kerry, Nixon White House, Nixon, Bob Haldeman, Chuck Colson, Kerry, Kerry, Kerry
There are: Kerry, Nixon, Kerry, Kerry, Nixon
Did Kerry: Kerry, Kerry, Bush, Dick Cheney, Tom DeLay, Bush, Kerry, Bush, Kerry
OJ On the Editorial Page
WSJ OpinionJournal
War and the Supreme Court
28 April 2004
1015 67 2R+,1R=
Will the: the President
The trend: Republican
The outcome: the President
Linda Chavez
Creators Syndicate
What happened after the war
28 April 2004
977 47 1D+,9D-,6D=,1R=
 Critics of: John Kerry, Democratic, President George W. Bush, Kerry
 On April: John Kerry, J. William Fulbright, Kerry, Kerry
 Kerry has: Kerry
 In his: Kerry
 The young: Kerry, Kerry
 He claimed: Kerry
 Kerry has: Kerry, Kerry
 Speaking on: John Kerry
 John Kerry: John Kerry
Cal Thomas
Tribune Media Services
The 'presumptive' nominee
28 April 2004
935 45 18D-,20D=,2R+,4R=
Often when: John Kerry, Kerry, Democratic, President Bush
Democrats' hatred: Democrats, the president
On April: John Kerry, Democratic, Kerry, Democrats, Bush, Bill Clinton, Kerry, Democrats
Ridgeway urged: Democrat
This is: John Edwards, Kerry, Hillary Rodham Clinton
It's hard: Bill and Hillary , Kerry, Howard Dean, Hillary Clinton, Dean, Dean, Hillary
Bill Clinton's: Bill Clinton, Democrats, Clinton, Republicans
Kerry's biggest: Kerry, President Bush, Kerry
Enter Hillary: Hillary Clinton, Democratic Party, Kerry, Democrats
Even if: Hillary, President Bush, Democrats
The column: Howard Dean, Hillary
( NOTE:: Joseph Califano, Jimmy Carter administration, Lyndon Johnson
WP Lead Editorial
Washington Post
A Start on Democracy
28 April 2004
610 40 1R+,5R-,4R=
THE BUSH: BUSH administration, administration
Much of: administration, Bush
Administration officials: Administration, administration, White House
Not much: administration, Bush administration, administration
Tony Blankley
Creators Syndicate
Kerry's fatal flaw
28 April 2004
929 36 8D-,8D=,1R+,1R-,4R=
Kerry's fatal: Kerry
 It would: John Kerry, Kerry
 Dwight Eisenhower: Dwight Eisenhower, Kennedy, Nixon, Jimmy Carter, Ronald Reagan, George H.W. Bush, Bill Clinton, George W. Bush
 Losers, also,: George McGovern, Walter Mondale, Al Gore, Gore
 Certainly, Howard: Howard Dean
 Quickly, think: John Kerry
 The ancient: John Kerry, John Kerry
 His friends: Kerry
 John Kerry's: John Kerry, Bush
William Safire
New York Times
Colin in the Cross-Fire
28 April 2004
929 32 1D+,3D-,1D=,12R+,3R-,14R=
Colin in: Colin
Our secretary: Colin Powell
The doves: the president, Cheney, Rummy
Hawks say:: the president
I was: Powell, Powell
But a: George Bush
Here's what: George Shultz
The new: Bush, Condi Rice, Don Rumsfeld, Colin Powell
First, Colin: Colin, Rummy, Condi Rice
That's the: Bush, Rummy, Colin, Powell, vice president, Dick Cheney
Powell gets: Powell, Bush, Powell
Presidents handle: L.B.J. , Nixon, Shultz, Pat Moynihan, Carter, Zbig Brzezinski, Cy Vance
Bush comes: Bush
Robert J. Samuelson
Washington Post
Keeping U.S. Jobs at Home
28 April 2004
939 29 1D+,3D-,3D=
John Kerry: John Kerry, Kerry, Kerry
Still, wouldn't: Kerry
What Kerry: Kerry, Kerry
But Kerry: Kerry
Joe Conason
New York Observer
Pro-life zealots ignore Republicans
28 April 2004
1006 17 8D+,1D=,5R+,2R-,13R=
Pro-life zealots: Republicans
04.28.04 -: Democrat, Republicans
In 1960,: John F. Kerry
Indeed, the: Kerry
In the: Kerry, Kerry
Two features: Kerry
Today's would-be: Kerry
How do: Democrat, Republicans
If that: Republicans, Kerry, Republicans
Among the: Republican Party, Arnold Schwarzenegger, Schwarzenegger
When the: Republicans, George Pataki, Rudolph Giuliani, Giuliani, Pataki, President
Speaking of: Bush, Paul Cellucci, Tom Ridge
Presumably, Mr.: Ridge, Cellucci, Republicans
Clarence Page
Chicago Tribune
A surprise running mate for Kerry: Calling Colin Powell
28 April 2004
1195 11 3D+,1D-,21D=,17R+,7R-,26R=
A surprise: Kerry, Colin Powell
Who will: John Kerry, Colin Powell
Yes, I: Powell, Republican, Kerry, John McCain, Republican, Kerry
McCain fed: McCain, Kerry, McCain, Bush
But more: Kerry, Republican, Bush
Nevertheless, as: Republicans, McCain, Kerry, McCain, Bush, Kerry, GOP
Last Sunday,: McCain, Republican, Kerry, Kerry, McCain
Both Bush: Bush, Kerry, McCain
And now: Kerry, Kerry, Bush, Bush
And Kerry: Kerry
Which is: Kerry, John McCain, Colin Powell
Kerry choosing: Kerry, Powell, Republican, Democrat
Like McCain,: McCain, Powell
Plus he: Kerry, McCain, Powell
On the: Powell, Democrat
Of course,: Powell, Kerry, Colin Powell, Kerry, Kerry, Powell, Bush, Colin, Kerry, Cheney, Rumsfeld
By all: Powell, McCain, Powell, Bush
To do: Powell, Powell
So maybe: Powell, Bush, Powell, Powell, Kerry, Powell
Either way,: Kerry
Claudia Rosett
Inactive
Oil-for-Terror
28 April 2004
1266
Thomas Sowell
Creators Syndicate
Bait-and-switch media
28 April 2004
785 0
Nicholas D. Kristof
Inactive
Trusting Iraqis?
28 April 2004
850
NYT Lead Editorial
New York Times
Those Illegal Farm Subsidies
28 April 2004
496 0 2R=
The glaring: Bush administration
The administration: administration
Anne Applebaum
Inactive
Preventive Medicine
28 April 2004
926
Walter E. Williams
Inactive
Printer-friendly version Poor education prognosis
28 April 2004
687