lying in ponds
The absurdity of partisanship
Home | About | Philosophy | Methods | Contact | FAQ | 2002 | 2003

Pundit Boxscore for Friday 23 April 2004

GOODBYE MARY MCGRORY: Yesterday brought the sad news of the passing of Mary McGrory, a beloved columnist for the Washington Star and Washington Post.

"The most luminous writer and clearest thinker in the business," New York Times columnist Maureen Dowd declared of McGrory at a tribute to her career several years ago. This opinion was widely held. Longtime Boston Globe editor Thomas Winship called her "the undisputed best handler of the English language in the news business." One of her rivals for that title, former Times columnist Russell Baker, noted her influence on later generations: McGrory was, he said, "a pioneering force in today's tell-it-like-it-is, show-them-no-mercy journalism."

Her career stretched from the Army-McCarthy hearings of 1954, when the unknown McGrory jolted the capital with her charming but rapier daily reports, to the Iraq war of 2003, on which she wavered with characteristic candor before coming down squarely in opposition in some of her last columns before a stroke silenced her voice. Her last column was published in The Washington Post on March 16, 2003, and she retired at the end of that year.

Her resume included the Pulitzer Prize and membership on the Nixon administration's notorious "enemies list."

"Mary was simply one of the best opinion columnists of her time," said Leonard Downie Jr. , The Washington Post's executive editor. "She wrote lyrically, and she never had difficulty expressing an opinion. But perhaps most impressive was Mary's reporting. She seemed to know everyone in politics, and in many other fields, besides. And her columns always revealed something to readers that they never would have otherwise known."

The Washington Post followed up this morning with an editorial, a collection of quotes, and a selected column from Ms. McGrory. The New York Times also remembers her with an editorial.



Lines in yellow indicate a substantive crossover column, meaning that the column is of opposite sign to the pundit's Normalized Total PI for the season, and contains at least five non-neutral partisan references.
Lines in gray indicate that the pundit has been classified as inactive, meaning that their columns are not currently being evaluated for partisanship.
Democratic references in blue, Republican in red, positive references in bold, negative in italics.
Author/
Affiliation
Title/
Date
words PI Partisan References
OJ On the Editorial Page
WSJ OpinionJournal
Blood Money
23 April 2004
981 100 2R+
BY JOHN: JOHN W. SNOW
One of: President Bush
Paul Krugman
New York Times
What Went Wrong?
23 April 2004
784 77 10R-,3R=
On April: Bush administration
It's now: administration, Bush
Why was: Bush administration
It quickly: President Bush, administration
Sure enough,: administration
Meanwhile, the: administration
Cronyism and: administration
More important,: President Bush
Now what?: Condoleezza Rice, Republican, Rick Santorum
Charles Krauthammer
Washington Post
Kerry Adrift
23 April 2004
963 54 2D+,16D-,2D=,1R+,1R-,4R=
Kerry Adrift: Kerry
In 1952: administration, administration
Electrifying, is: Democrats, George Bush
"If I'm: John Kerry, Kerry
That leaves: Kerry
The idea: Kerry, Democratic, Kerry
Which may: the president, Bush, Kerry
The answer: John Kerry, Bush
I give: Kerry, Kerry, Howard Dean
But his: Democratic, Democratic, Hubert Humphrey
Kerry's political: Kerry, Bush, Kerry, Kerry
David Ignatius
Inactive
New Course for Iraq
23 April 2004
902
Mona Charen
Creators Syndicate
Fighting words
23 April 2004
853 0 4D=,4R=
 There is: William Cohen
 One hates: Tim Roemer, Attorney General John Ashcroft, Fred Fielding, President Reagan, Secretary of State Colin Powell
 In the: Janet Reno, Sandy Berger
NYT Lead Editorial
New York Times
Depressing News on Depression
23 April 2004
605 0
Bob Herbert
Inactive
A Muscular Idealism
23 April 2004
935
WP Lead Editorial
Washington Post
Good News on Development
23 April 2004
516 0
Daniel Henninger
WSJ OpinionJournal
F-Word Fight
23 April 2004
1462 0