lying in ponds
The absurdity of partisanship
Home | About | Philosophy | Methods | Contact | FAQ | 2002 | 2003

Pundit Boxscore for Tuesday 20 April 2004

ABNORMAL NORMALIZATION NORMAL AGAIN: This weekend the total number of 2004 Republican references surpassed the number of Democratic references for the first time. It's normal for the ruling party to dominate the national discussion, but the intense interest in the Democratic primaries early in the year strongly tilted the balance the other way. The scoring system this year attempts to correct for distortion caused by an imbalance of references to the two parties, which could change the partisanship scores of some pundits by a few points. The current normalization factors are shown in the annotation at the top of the Top Ten list. Today's Republican normalization of 0.98 means that references to Republicans have been slightly more prevalent this year, and are therefore given slightly less weight than Democratic references. The effect on scoring will be negligible until the references become more unbalanced.



Lines in yellow indicate a substantive crossover column, meaning that the column is of opposite sign to the pundit's Normalized Total PI for the season, and contains at least five non-neutral partisan references.
Lines in gray indicate that the pundit has been classified as inactive, meaning that their columns are not currently being evaluated for partisanship.
Democratic references in blue, Republican in red, positive references in bold, negative in italics.
Author/
Affiliation
Title/
Date
words PI Partisan References
Molly Ivins
Creators Syndicate
Be there
20 April 2004
1056 64 7R-,4R=
The March: Bush Administration, Bush
Anti-choice policies: George W. Bush, Reagan
Republican women,: Republican, George W. Bush, Republican, President Bush
Barbara Bush,: Barbara Bush, Nancy Reagan, President Bush
OJ On the Editorial Page
WSJ OpinionJournal
Bush's Brahimi Gamble
20 April 2004
1083 60 1D=,6R-,3R=
Bush's Brahimi: Bush
One mystery: Bush Administration
"Whatever" is: President Bush
Perhaps the: the President
The one-sided: Bush
The destructive: Bush Administration
Yet leaks: White House
To claim: George W. Bush, John Kerry
One reason: White House
Paul Krugman
New York Times
Questions of Interest
20 April 2004
834 50 1R+,1R=
That last: Gregory Mankiw, the president
Robert Scheer
Creators Syndicate
With God on his side
20 April 2004
863 39 3R+,10R-,5R=
04.20.04 -: George W. Bush, the president
Of course,: Bush
But not: the president, George H.W. Bush
In contrast,: Bush
Asked by: former president, Bush
Reading the: Bush, former president
Thus, if: George W. , Secretary of State Colin Powell, Powell
That Powell: Powell, President Bush, president
After the: the president
The president: The president
E. J. Dionne Jr.
Washington Post
Kerry's Terrorism Offensive
20 April 2004
1028 28 12D+,5D-,3D=,7R+,14R-,9R=
Kerry's Terrorism: Kerry
Here is: John Kerry, President Bush
It wasn't: Republicans
Ronald Reagan: Ronald Reagan, President Bush, George W. Bush
But the: Kerry
The current: president, Bush
Kerry's approach: Kerry, Kerry, Democrats, Democrats
"Terrorism and: Kerry, Kerry
In making: Bush, Kerry, Democrats, administration, Republican, the president
In 2002,: Democrats, Bush, the president, Democrats, Republicans, Democrats, Bush, Bush
But this: Bush, administration, Bush
This creates: Kerry, Bush, Bush
Kerry said: Kerry
Bush's campaign: Bush, the president, Kerry, Bush, Marc Racicot, Democrat, Bush, Racicot, Kerry
The Bush: Bush, Bush, Kerry, Bush
David Brooks
New York Times
Clearing the Air
20 April 2004
827 28 2D-,1D=,6R+,3R-,6R=
Nonetheless, over: Bush
The first: President Bush, Clinton, Bush
The Bush: Bush administration, administration
The administration's: administration, Bush, Bush
The most: Bush, Bush
The administration: administration
Nonetheless, for: Democratic, Bush, Democrats, Bush, administration
How high: Bush
NYT Lead Editorial
New York Times
Which Powell Is Which?
20 April 2004
941 23 3R+,11R-,21R=
Which Powell: Powell
Colin Powell: Colin Powell
For three: Powell, administration, Powell, Vice President Dick Cheney, Defense Secretary Donald Rumsfeld, White House
No one: Powell
The publication: Powell, the president, Cheney, Bush, Cheney, Rumsfeld, Condoleezza Rice, Powell
When the: Powell
Mr. Woodward: Powell, Bush, Powell
After letting: Powell, the president, Powell, White House
What we: Powell, Bush, Powell, administration
Mr. Powell,: Powell, Reagan White House, Powell, Powell, Powell, Bush administration
WP Lead Editorial
Washington Post
The U.N. in Iraq
20 April 2004
725 14 3D-,2R-,2R=
THE DIFFICULT: John F. Kerry, Democratic
The Bush: Bush administration
The American: Bush administration, President Bush, Democratic, Bush
Richard Cohen
Washington Post
Bicycling to War
20 April 2004
968 11 9R+,6R-,12R=
I offer: Condi Rice, Dick Cheney, George Bush
The "bicycle": Bush, the president
For a: Bush, the president, Bush
But as: Deputy Defense Secretary Paul Wolfowitz, the president
I confess: Bush
My guess: Cheney, Bush, Cheney, Bush, White House, Bush, Cheney, Colin Powell, Cheney, vice president
Whatever the: Bush
This is: Bush, Powell, Bush
Those, though,: Powell, Bush
Thomas Oliphant
Boston Globe
The fiction of Israeli 'withdrawal' from Gaza
nobr> December
1003 10 1D-,1D=,3R+,5R-
By Thomas: President Bush, Bush
Shortly after: the president
This month,: Bush, Clinton
The United: Bush, John Kerry
In embracing: Bush, Bush
For Bush: Bush
David Ignatius
Inactive
Is China's Economy Overheating?
20 April 2004
872
Pete du Pont
Inactive
Oil Is Not Well
20 April 2004
1203