lying in ponds
The absurdity of partisanship
Home | About | Philosophy | Methods | Contact | FAQ | 2002 | 2003

Pundit Boxscore for Tuesday 6 April 2004

SCHEER TROPE COLLECTS ANOTHER VICTIM: As Spinsanity has documented, errors such as the myth that Ken Lay slept in the Lincoln bedroom during the Clinton administration often refuse to die, because they are picked up by others even long after being debunked. Another moldy story is the Taliban aid myth created by Robert Scheer. The latest victim was Kevin Drum at The Washington Monthly, who referred to "Bush's conciliatory attitude toward the Taliban during his first few months in office", citing Mr. Scheer's three-year-old article. To his great credit, Mr. Drum then corrected the record:

UPDATE: My critics are right. The "conciliatory attitude" crack about the Taliban was a cheap shot. The money Scheer is talking about in the linked article was humanitarian aid delivered through the UN.



Lines in yellow indicate a substantive crossover column, meaning that the column is of opposite sign to the pundit's Normalized Total PI for the season, and contains at least five non-neutral partisan references.
Lines in gray indicate that the pundit has been classified as inactive, meaning that their columns are not currently being evaluated for partisanship.
Democratic references in blue, Republican in red, positive references in bold, negative in italics.
Author/
Affiliation
Title/
Date
words PI Partisan References
Richard Cohen
Washington Post
The Buck Doesn't Stop
6 April 2004
935 80 3D+,1R+,18R-,3R=
What happened: Donald Rumsfeld, Rumsfeld, Bush administration
In his: Rumsfeld, Rumsfeld
But from: the president, administration, Dick Cheney, John Kerry, vice president, Cheney
In his: Rumsfeld
That is: Bush administration, administration, Rumsfeld, Bushies, Clinton, Clinton
Instead, the: Bush, Reagan
That quality: Rumsfeld, Bush administration, Bush
What is: administration, Colin Powell
Robert Scheer
Creators Syndicate
The beginning of the end
6 April 2004
784 75 2D+,1R+,5R-
04.06.04 -: Bush administration
To its: George W. Bush, Jimmy Carter, President Bush, Bill Clinton
Yet, under: administration
And even: Bush
Instead, his: administration
Paul Krugman
New York Times
The Mercury Scandal
6 April 2004
825 75 9R-,3R=
If you: Bush administration
A few: Bush administration
Sulfur dioxide: administration
The answer: Bush administration, Republican, administration, administration
Mercury is: administration
A Yawngate: administration, Bush, White House, administration
David Brooks
New York Times
Fly the Partisan Skies
6 April 2004
840 67 4D-,1R+,1R-
The way: Karl Rove
The experience: George Soros
In addition,: Democrats, Kerry, Dean
Right Wing: George Bush
Thomas Oliphant
Boston Globe
Blatant Bush tilt toward big oil
6 April 2004
1045 60 5D+,4D=,4R+,17R-
Blatant Bush: Bush
On this: President Bush, administration
In a: Bush, administration
For the: Vice President Dick Cheney
And in: Bush, John Kerry, Bush, Kerry, The president
Here's what: Bush, Bush, Kerry
As for: Republican, Democratic
But not: President Bush, Spencer Abraham, administration, White House, Bush
No one,: John Kerry, Bush
The politics: Democrats, Kerry, Republican, John McCain
Kerry doesn't: Kerry
It is: Kerry, McCain
Molly Ivins
Creators Syndicate
Iraq: it's a crowd pleaser
6 April 2004
830 57 1D=,1R+,5R-
The Bush: Bush administration
The "we: administration
I like: Bushies
Then there's: Aiken, President Bush
I suspect: George W. Bush
If I: John Kerry
Brendan Miniter
WSJ OpinionJournal
Rice's Best Defense
6 April 2004
1059 52 4D-,3D=,8R+,1R-,5R=
Rice's Best: Rice
This week: Condoleezza Rice, Rice
1. Commission: Thomas Kean, Lee Hamilton, Clinton, Attorney General John Ashcroft, President Bush, Attorney General Janet Reno, Bill Clinton
2. How: Rice, Bush administration
This second: Rice, Bush administration
Take missile: Ronald Reagan, Clinton administration
All of: President Bush, administration
John Kerry: John Kerry, Kerry
Sept. 11: Bush administration
NYT Lead Editorial
New York Times
Obsessing About the Calendar
6 April 2004
707 50 1R+,4R-,1R=
President Bush: President Bush, Bush
So far,: administration
Allowing the: Bush, the president, Richard Lugar
OJ On the Editorial Page
WSJ OpinionJournal
Crunch Time in Baghdad
6 April 2004
1190 8 1D-,2R+,2R-,8R=
Bush must: Bush
The next: President Bush
Marines were: Bush
Americans will: Bush
Partly this: Richard Lugar, Joe Biden
Yesterday, Mr.: Bush
With elections: Bush Administration
While we're: Bush, Paul Wolfowitz, Rudy Giuliani
We trust: Bush, Bush
E. J. Dionne Jr.
Washington Post
'God Bless Atheism'
6 April 2004
799 0
David Ignatius
Inactive
The CIA's Dissidents
6 April 2004
860
Thomas Sowell
Creators Syndicate
Fixing the jury system
6 April 2004
808 0
WP Lead Editorial
Washington Post
A Necessary Fight
6 April 2004
527 0