lying in ponds
The absurdity of partisanship
Home | About | Philosophy | Methods | Contact | FAQ | 2002 | 2003

Pundit Boxscore for Wednesday 28 January 2004

TAPPED ON NOONAN: Nick Confessore at Tapped doesn't think too highly of Peggy Noonan's recent column on Wesley Clark:

Like Charles Krauthammer, Wall Street Journal columnist Peggy Noonan has a reprehensible tendency to attribute mental imbalance to people with whom she disagrees. Her latest column is a case in point. She invents a flip-flop for which to attack Wesley Clark, and prattles on for sentence after sentence about his mental state.
. . .
Noonan doesn't exactly possess the most penetrating mind in punditry. But even so, it's amazing that she leaps to mental illness to explain positions and opinions of Clark's for which no mental illness is necessary.



Lines in yellow indicate a substantive crossover column, meaning that the column is of opposite sign to the pundit's Normalized Total PI for the season, and contains at least five non-neutral partisan references.
Lines in gray indicate that the pundit has been classified as inactive, meaning that their columns are not currently being evaluated for partisanship.
Democratic references in blue, Republican in red, positive references in bold, negative in italics.
Author/
Affiliation
Title/
Date
words PI Partisan References
Joe Conason
New York Observer
Bush's war stories simply don't fly
28 January 2004
998 68 1D+,3D=,16R-,5R=
Bush's war: Bush
01.28.04 -: George W. Bush, Karen Hughes, Bush
In light: Bush
The issue: Wesley Clark, the President, Democratic, Clark
As the: the President, Bush, Bush, Bush
The facts,: Hughes
George W.: George W. Bush, Bush
But in: Bush
He never: Republican, Bush
In fact,: Bush, Bush
So Mr.: Bush, Bill Clinton
What the: Bush, Bush
OJ On the Editorial Page
WSJ OpinionJournal
So Where's the WMD?
28 January 2004
916 67 3D-,2D=,3R+,1R=
Anti-Bush partisans: Bush
His answers,: Bush, Democratic, John Kerry, President Bush
The reason: Kerry, Clinton Administration, Bush Administration
By all: Democrats
Tony Blankley
Creators Syndicate
Don't you know there's a war on?
28 January 2004
941 33 2D-,3D=,1R=
Listening to: Joe Lieberman, Democratic
Of course: President Bush
In nine: Joe Lieberman
Whatever each: Lieberman
In the: Democratic
NYT Lead Editorial
New York Times
Defrosting the Primaries
28 January 2004
599 21 3D+,7D-,9D=
Senator John: John Kerry, Democratic
Howard Dean: Howard Dean, Dean
Senator Kerry: Kerry, John Edwards, Wesley Clark, Edwards, Dean
Representative Dennis: Dennis Kucinich, Al Sharpton, Joseph Lieberman, Lieberman, Clark, Clark, Lieberman
The serious: Kerry, Democrats, Kerry
Cal Thomas
Tribune Media Services
Trouble on Bush's right?
28 January 2004
926 10 1D-,1D=,12R+,10R-,7R=
Trouble on: Bush
It would: President Bush, Mike Pence, Pence, Republican, Bush, White House, Bush, Reagan, pPence
Pence's indictment: Pence
Congressional Republicans: Congressional Republicans, Bush administration
In his: Pence, Republicans, Reaganite, Republicans, the president, Ted Kennedy
About prescription: Pence, the president
Pence added,: Pence
There is: President Bush, Republicans
One Heritage: George Bush, Bill Clinton, Bush
These good: the president, Pence
Are they: White House
Ask President: President Bush
Thomas Oliphant
Boston Globe
A strong finish, broad support
28 January 2004
933 9 9D+,6D-,16D=,3R=
JOHN KERRY: JOHN KERRY, Democratic
With months: Kerry
Kerry must: Kerry, Wesley Clark, John Edwards, Howard Dean
In his: Kerry, Kerry, Democratic
He also: Dean, Dean
This was: President Bush, Kerry
However, Kerry's: Kerry, Kerry
As it: Dean, Democrats, Democrats
It was,: Kerry, Bush, Dean, Bush administration
Dean's sole: Dean, Dean, Dean, Kerry
Geography may: Dean
The month's: Dean, Kerry, Edwards, Dean, Kerry, Dean
WP Lead Editorial
Washington Post
New Hampshire Lessons
28 January 2004
734 4 6D+,9D-,9D=,2R-
IF THE: Democratic, John F. Kerry, Kerry, Kerry, Kerry, Howard Dean
But the: Dean, Kerry, Dean, Dean
Mr. Kerry: Kerry, Dean, John Edwards, Wesley K. Clark, Joseph I. Lieberman, Dean, Edwards, Edwards, Clark, Clark, Lieberman
One vivid: Democratic, George W. Bush, the president, Kerry, Dean
Nicholas D. Kristof
Inactive
Loss of Innocence
28 January 2004
816
Linda Chavez
Creators Syndicate
Those old cardboard boxes
28 January 2004
795 0
Anne Applebaum
Inactive
Honesty in Izvestia
28 January 2004
910
Clarence Page
Chicago Tribune
Reparations on trial--briefly
28 January 2004
856 0
Thomas Sowell
Creators Syndicate
Third world sweatshops: part II
28 January 2004
713 0
Claudia Rosett
Inactive
Weapons of Mass Distraction
28 January 2004
1290
William Safire
New York Times
At the Brokered Convention
28 January 2004
982 0 42D=,3R=
Here we: Democratic
A brief: Democratic, Kerry, Dean, Edwards, Clark
Then came: Kerry, Dean, Democratic, Bill Richardson, Bush
The dispute: Edwards, Clark
"The fight: Edwards, Clark, Kerry, Dean
That competition: Kerry
"Edwards has: Edwards, Clark, Kerry, Clark
"I'm yanking: Kerry, Edwards
To the: McAuliffe
"We're happier: Kerry, Clark, Edwards
What's notable: Kerry, Dean, Kennedy, Johnson, Reagan, Bush, Dean
"Never. Edwards: Edwards, Clark, Kerry
"Because we'll: Kerry
Or Dean: Dean, Clark, Edwards, Kerry, Lieberman
The chair: Hillary
Jim Hoagland
Inactive
The Kurds' Best Hope
28 January 2004
846
Walter E. Williams
Inactive
Sweatshop exploitation
28 January 2004
699