lying in ponds
The absurdity of partisanship
Home | About | Philosophy | Methods | Contact | FAQ | 2002 | 2003

Pundit Boxscore for Tuesday 20 January 2004

GOOD CORRECTION: According to the Code of Ethics of the Society of Professional Journalists, "journalists should admit mistakes and correct them promptly". Molly Ivins shows how it's done by plainly apologizing ("Crow Eaten Here") at the end of two recent columns -- one for borrowing a line without crediting the source, and one for attributing information to the wrong source. Kudos to Ms. Ivins.

BAD CORRECTION: David Brooks took some heat for unfairly associating criticism of neoconservatives with anti-Semitism in a recent column. While Mr. Brooks attempted to explain and apologize, he apparently did it in an e-mail to some readers rather than where it belongs, in a subsequent column.

NO CORRECTION: Although Charles Krauthammer wrote a column which clearly manipulated a Howard Dean quote and altered its meaning, he has yet to address the issue as far as I'm aware.



Lines in yellow indicate a substantive crossover column, meaning that the column is of opposite sign to the pundit's Normalized Total PI for the season, and contains at least five non-neutral partisan references.
Lines in gray indicate that the pundit has been classified as inactive, meaning that their columns are not currently being evaluated for partisanship.
Democratic references in blue, Republican in red, positive references in bold, negative in italics.
Author/
Affiliation
Title/
Date
words PI Partisan References
Robert Scheer
Creators Syndicate
Give Iraqis the election they want
20 January 2004
770 100 4R-
With the: Bush administration
The U.S.,: President Bush, the president
The White: White House
Richard Cohen
Washington Post
Lawless in Guantanamo
20 January 2004
843 100 3R-
No one: Donald H. Rumsfeld, Rumsfeld
These are: the president
Molly Ivins
Creators Syndicate
It's about money
20 January 2004
1007 96 2D+,21R-,1R=
01.20.04 -: George W. Bush, Bush
When Bush: Bush, Bush, Bush
It is: the president
I anticipate: Bill Clinton, George W. Bush
There are,: the president, Bush administration, The president
In another: Bush, Bush, Tom Harkin, Republican, White House
Now, in: administration, administration, administration
We will: the president
Bush said: Bush, White House, Bush, Republican Party
Paul Krugman
New York Times
Going for Broke
20 January 2004
874 94 2D+,13R-,1R=
According to: George Bush, Bush
Mr. Bush: Bush, F.D.R.
What do: Bush
But that's: Bush
Judging from: Bush
But some: Bush
The most: Republican
A less: Bush, administration
Meanwhile, the: Republican National Committee, Wesley Clark
Some cynical: Bush, Bush
Karl Rove: Karl Rove
David Brooks
New York Times
Keeping the Faith
20 January 2004
970 50 18D+,4D-,5D=,1R-,2R=
At the: John Edwards, Kucinich, Edwards, Dean, Kerry, Kucinich, Edwards
We've learned: Democratic Party, Kerry, Edwards, Democratic Party, Democrats, Democrats, Bush
Instead, if: Democratic
She remembers: Democrats, Democrat
She remembers: John F. Kennedy, George McGovern, Democratic, Democratic Party
The other: Reagan, Republican, Bill Clinton
Like one: Dean, Dean, Edwards, Dean, Kerry, Clark
OJ On the Editorial Page
WSJ OpinionJournal
Drunken GOP Sailors
20 January 2004
1065 38 2D+,7D=,1R+,9R-,7R=
Drunken GOP: GOP
Even Bill: Bill Clinton, Democratic Congress
In tonight's: President Bush
But if: Administration
What's more,: Ted Stevens
GOP leaders: GOP
The 3%: Sarbanes, Oxley
The bottom: Clinton
Profligate President: President
Lyndon Johnson: Lyndon Johnson
Richard Nixon: Richard Nixon
Gerald Ford: Gerald Ford
Jimmy Carter: Jimmy Carter
Ronald Reagan: Ronald Reagan
George H.W.: George H.W. Bush
Bill Clinton: Bill Clinton
George W.: George W. Bush
Amazing as: GOP
As we: GOP, Tom Daschle, Daschle, GOP
The truth: Bush, President Bush
Cal Thomas
Tribune Media Services
Pickering's recess appointment
20 January 2004
996 24 4D-,9D=,4R+,1R-,11R=
Reacting to: President George Bush, Jon Corzine, Corzine, the president, Democrats, Republicans
The recess: Republican, Democratic, Bill Clinton, Republicans, Clinton, Democrats, Bush
There is: Orrin Hatch, Clinton, President Clinton, President Bush
If the: Democrats, Republicans
Bush's naming: Bush, President Jimmy Carter, the president
Liberal Democrats,: Democrats
The Pickering: President Bush, Bush, Democratic
Pickering was: President Bush
The president: The president, Republican
NYT Lead Editorial
New York Times
The Iowa Surprise
20 January 2004
504 11 5D+,5D-,6D=,2R-,1R=
A great: Howard Dean, Richard Gephardt, Democrats, George Bush, Bush
John Kerry,: John Kerry, John Edwards
The fact: Democratic, Kerry, Edwards, Dean, Kerry, President Bush, Edwards, Dean, Gephardt
Mr. Gephardt's: Gephardt, Dean, Kerry
WP Lead Editorial
Washington Post
After Iowa
20 January 2004
779 9 6D+,8D-,8D=,1R=
FOR MONTHS: Democratic, Howard Dean, John F. Kerry, John Edwards, Dean
This is: Dean, Dean, Kerry, Edwards, Dean
For Rep.: Richard A. Gephardt, Wesley K. Clark, Joseph I. Lieberman, Clark, Kerry, Clark
Whatever one's: Dean, Democratic
There are: Dean, Kerry, Kerry
This is: President Bush, Democratic Party
David S. Broder
Washington Post
Four-Star Staying Power?
20 January 2004
1030 7 6D+,6D-,17D=,6R+,3R-,6R=
PEMBROKE, N.H.: Republican, Wesley K. Clark
At least: Clark
John McCain: John McCain, George W. Bush
That Clark: Clark, McCain
Although he: Republican, McCain, Clark
While they: Clark, Reaganesque
True patriotism,: George Bush
True faith,: Democratic Party
All this: Bush, Democrats, Howard Dean, Clark, Clinton, Reaganesque, Democrats, Bush, Dean
Dortha Morrils: Dean, Clark, Bush, Dean
But the: Clark, Dean
Dean's support: Dean, Clark
He has: Bush, Dean, Clark, Bush, Clark, Clark, George McGovern, Democrats
What makes: Clark, Dean
Can the: Reagan, Democrat, Democratic
Brendan Miniter
WSJ OpinionJournal
Capps Off
20 January 2004
540 0
David Ignatius
Inactive
Iraq's Halting Progress
20 January 2004
878
Robert J. Samuelson
Washington Post
Presidential Scorekeeping
20 January 2004
1067 0 2D+,6D=,8R+,6R-,13R=
In 1962: Eisenhower, Eisenhower, the president, Eisenhower, Eisenhower
Even now,: Eisenhower, Eisenhower, Lyndon Johnson, Ronald Reagan, Bill Clinton, Jimmy Carter
What recalls: George W. Bush, White House, Paul O'Neill, administration, Bush, O'Neill, administration, Reagan, Vice President Cheney, O'Neill
Or consider: Truman, Truman, Truman, Franklin Roosevelt
Some pitfalls: O'Neill, Bush, administration, the president, O'Neill, Bush
But these: Truman, Eisenhower
Bush's reputation: Bush, Bush