lying in ponds
The absurdity of partisanship
Home | About | Philosophy | Methodology | Contact | 2002

Pundit Boxscore for Monday 9 June 2003

DEAN ON POLITICAL ARROGANCE: In response to a post here last Thursday, the always-fascinating Dean Esmay contemplates those who believe that "one of America's two major parties is thoroughly corrupt and evil":

As I've gotten older I've realized that this is a titanic form of arrogance.

Arrogance? Yes. Because here's what it boils down to: "if only people would listen to me then they would have to agree with me, because what I believe is obviously right."

It's hard. I think we all sometimes fall prey to this. Some of us just do it more than others, or more intensely than others. One cure is to be confronted with the fact that you're wrong about one of your core beliefs. Sooner or later, most of us are confronted with such evidence. The question is, do we ignore it, rationalize our way around it, or take the blow and allow our minds to be changed?

Read the whole thing. Dean also says some remarkably kind things about Lying in Ponds, and provocatively writes that " it might even be said that political partisanship, in the Western Democratic style, is the greatest cultural achievement of the past three or four centuries". I probably won't be able to resist commenting on that.



Author/
Affiliation
Title/
Date
words PI Partisan References
William Safire
New York Times
After 1,000 Days
9 June 2003
755 50 1R+: President Bush
1R=
William Raspberry
Washington Post
Good for Them That's Got
9 June 2003
795 38 1D+: Democrats
3R+: Republicans, president, David Stockman
8R-: administration, The president, Reagan administration, Reagan, Reagan, president, Bush administration, administration
1D=, 3R=
Robert L. Bartley
WSJ OpinionJournal
Joining LaRouche
9 June 2003
1212 35 7R+: Wolfowitz, Paul Wolfowitz, Richard Perle, Condoleezza Rice, Colin Powell, Bush, administration
1R-: Bush Administration
9R=
Bob Herbert
Inactive
Where Fear Rules the Street
9 June 2003
888 0 3D=
Fred Hiatt
Inactive
Challenging Bush's World View
9 June 2003
849 0 4D=, 10R=