lying in ponds
The absurdity of partisanship
Home | About | Philosophy | Methods | Contact | FAQ | 2002 | 2003

Pundit Boxscore for Friday 11 February 2005

AFTER SAFIRE: I meant to link to this earlier, but Jack Shafer of Slate wrote extensively back in December about some possible replacements for William Safire on The New York Times Op-Ed page. His nominees are Heather Mac Donald ("flings cats into the temple of liberalism from her sinecure at the Manhattan Institute, a conservative-libertarian stink tank"), Alex Kozinski ("It's a tragedy that in a nation of immigrants, we don't have a Times columnist with a funny accent who lives in Los Angeles"), Steve Chapman ("a polymath, a creative policy wonk, a tap-dancing writer, a true son of liberty, a failed Christian, a knucklehead when it comes to the Novak case, and a Great American (for a Texan)"), and even George W. Bush's cousin, John Ellis ("an inside-politics guy, something that the op-ed page will lack when Safire leaves").



Lines in yellow indicate a substantive crossover column, meaning that the column is of opposite sign to the pundit's Normalized Total PI for the season, and contains at least five non-neutral partisan references.
Lines in gray indicate that the pundit has been classified as inactive, meaning that their columns are not currently being evaluated for partisanship.
Democratic references in blue, Republican in red, positive references in bold, negative in italics.
Author/
Affiliation
Title/
Date
words PI Partisan References
Ann Coulter
Universal Press Syndicate
The little Injun that could
11 February 2005
1451 100 7D-,1R+
If Ward: Howard Dean, Democratic National Committee
Churchill already: John Kerry
Come to: Hillary, Al Sharpton
Churchill's claim: John Kerry
In addition: John Kerry
In 1990,: Ben Nighthorse Campbell
Mona Charen
Creators Syndicate
Iran: The next Nicaragua?
11 February 2005
844 100 5R+
 President Bush's: President Bush
 And like: Rick Santorum, Reagan
 President Bush: President Bush, Reagan
E. J. Dionne Jr.
Washington Post
Holes in a Web of Budget Deceit
11 February 2005
934 95 1D=,19R-
Let us: Bush administration
More than: President Bush, the president
The president's: The president, administration, administration
What's particularly: administration, Bush, administration
Oh, yes,: administration
As one: Bush, Bush, Bush
Are those: Bush, Democrat, Bush
Personally, those: Bush
And at: the president
Every commentator: president
The budget: The president
Paul Krugman
New York Times
Bush's Class-War Budget
11 February 2005
906 72 1D+,1D=,1R+,13R-,2R=
Bush's Class-War: Bush
It may: President Bush, Democrats
And the: administration, the first President George Bush
It so: Bush
The question: Bush
Until now,: administration
But here: Bush
Until now,: administration, Bush
Why shouldn't: Bush
Here's a: Bush
On the: Bush
Democrats have: Democrats, Bush administration, Bush, Bush
David Ignatius
Inactive
Bush's Clark Kent
11 February 2005
1020
Bob Herbert
Inactive
Torture, American Style
11 February 2005
826
Charles Krauthammer
Washington Post
Why the Palestinians Came to the Table
11 February 2005
851 0
Daniel Henninger
WSJ OpinionJournal
Give Iraq's Voters
11 February 2005
1101 0