lying in ponds
The absurdity of partisanship
Home | About | Philosophy | Methods | Contact | FAQ | 2002 | 2003

Pundit Boxscore for Wednesday 25 February 2004

CROSSOVER COHEN: I made a programming mistake at the beginning of the month in the code which was supposed to recognize "crossover columns" in the daily boxscores and columnist pages. Now the problem is fixed and columns will be highlighted in yellow when they lean the opposite way of a pundit's usual party orientation. As an attempt to exclude non-substantive (accidental or offhand references) efforts, a crossover column must also contain at least five non-neutral party references. So if a Republican pundit wrote a column with three positive Democratic and two negative Democratic references, that would count as a crossover column -- a very lenient standard. Look at yesterday's boxscore and you'll see a Richard Cohen crossover column on Ralph Nader -- it's his second in a row, dropping him almost out of the Top Ten.



Lines in yellow indicate a substantive crossover column, meaning that the column is of opposite sign to the pundit's Normalized Total PI for the season, and contains at least five non-neutral partisan references.
Lines in gray indicate that the pundit has been classified as inactive, meaning that their columns are not currently being evaluated for partisanship.
Democratic references in blue, Republican in red, positive references in bold, negative in italics.
Author/
Affiliation
Title/
Date
words PI Partisan References
OJ On the Editorial Page
WSJ OpinionJournal
For Better or for Worse?
25 February 2004
1019 100 3R+
CAMBRIDGE, Mass.--President: President Bush
A common: President Bush
Whether one: President Bush
William Safire
New York Times
Return to Riga
25 February 2004
771 100 2R-
I datelined: Bush's administration
But the: Bush
NYT Lead Editorial
New York Times
Putting Bias in the Constitution
25 February 2004
524 100 8R-
With his: President Bush
If Mr.: Bush, the president
President Bush's: President Bush
In his: President Bush, The president
The Constitution: President Bush, President Bush
Cal Thomas
Tribune Media Services
Bush strikes back
25 February 2004
840 68 11D-,8D=,10R+,2R=
Bush strikes: Bush
Tired of: John Kerry, Democratic Party, President Bush, Republican, Bush, Democratic, Kerry, the president
The initial: Bush, Kerry, Kerry, the president
There is: Republican National Committee, Bush, Kerry, the president
During testimony: Kerry, Kerry
It is: Kerry
On Feb.: Kerry, Bill Clinton, Bob Kerrey, Bill Clinton, John Kerry, Democrats
Kerry continued,: Kerry
The Bush: Bush, Kerry, Kerry, the president
Molly Ivins
Creators Syndicate
Bait-and-switch Bush
25 February 2004
974 62 3R+,16R-,2R=
Bait-and-switch Bush: Bush
02.25.04 -: Rod Paige
Paige is: Paige
Ten other: Republican, Republicans, President Bush
Except, as: administration, administration, Bush
Here's a: Bush, Bush, Bushies
The Public: Bush
My personal: Bush, administration
This administration: administration, Bushies
When Bush: Bush
So what: president, Dick Cheney, Cheney
Thomas Sowell
Creators Syndicate
Random thoughts
25 February 2004
779 60 1D-,3R+,1R-
When the: the president, Paul O'Neill
People who: president, President Bush, Bush
WP Lead Editorial
Washington Post
Debasing the Constitution
25 February 2004
499 33 2R-,4R=
WITH THESE: President Bush, Bush
The president's: The president, Bush
Mr. Bush: Bush, The President
Tony Blankley
Creators Syndicate
What makes John Kerry tick?
25 February 2004
917 12 1D-,5D=,2R=
What makes: John Kerry
I disagree: George Bush, John Kerry
While we: George W. Bush
But what: John Kerry, John Kerry
Is John: John Kerry
But if: John Kerry
Robert J. Samuelson
Washington Post
A Phony Jobs Debate
25 February 2004
1074 8 2D-,5D=,1R+,2R-,3R=
The jobs: John Kerry, John Edwards, President Bush, Bush administration
The contrast: administration
Facing a: Bush
We don't: Gore, Kerry, Edwards, Democrats, Bush, President Bill Clinton, Bush
Anne Applebaum
Inactive
'I Am Victim'
25 February 2004
844
Clarence Page
Chicago Tribune
Here's why there is no `White History Month'
25 February 2004
904 0 1R=
Good for: Jim Gilmore
Claudia Rosett
Inactive
A New Job for Kay
25 February 2004
1440
Nicholas D. Kristof
Inactive
Calling the Kettle Black
25 February 2004
790
Linda Chavez
Creators Syndicate
The Passion
25 February 2004
765 0
George F. Will
Washington Post
The Left's Anti-Semitic Chic
25 February 2004
833 0 1D=
Europe's susceptibility: President Kennedy
Walter E. Williams
Inactive
Congressional miracles
25 February 2004
680